Red Dead Redemption 2 Player Discovers Heartbreaking Detail About Arthur Morgan's Love Life

An attentive Red Dead Redemption 2 player has uncovered a poignant detail about Arthur Morgan's ill-fated love life in Rockstar's open-world Western. While much of the game’s side content revolves around Arthur’s complicated relationship with Mary Linton, his journal entries reveal a deeper layer of regret—one that hints at feelings for another member of the Van der Linde gang.

For over six years, players have been uncovering hidden gems within Red Dead Redemption 2. The game’s unparalleled attention to detail continues to captivate audiences, making it a timeless masterpiece. Even veteran players who have explored the game since its 2018 release are still finding new and surprising details.

One such discovery comes from Redditor ComradRogers, who found an intriguing page in Arthur Morgan’s journal. In an entry written during the gang’s time at Horseshoe Overlook, Arthur reflects on Jack Marston’s future and makes a startling admission: “Perhaps I should have married” Abigail, John Marston’s partner. He follows this thought with, “Part of me has always thought that, yet, God damn you, Mary!” This bittersweet note reveals Arthur’s private regrets—emotions he would never voice aloud to the gang. His words show a tug-of-war between what might have been and the unshakable hold Mary Linton has on his heart.

Arthur Questions If He Should’ve Married Abigail

Another user in the Reddit thread offered a compelling interpretation of Arthur's journal entry. They suggested that Arthur’s reflection wasn’t necessarily about romantic feelings for Abigail but rather a recognition that she might have been a better match for him. As the commenter put it, “Abigail would be a better fit for him… if he loved her. He’s ‘damning’ Mary because that’s who his heart belongs to. He wishes he loved Abigail, as it would have made life easier.”

This depth of character is part of what makes Red Dead Redemption 2’s storytelling so exceptional. The game’s nuanced writing leaves room for multiple valid interpretations, allowing players to connect with the characters on a deeply personal level.

What’s Next for the Red Dead Franchise?

While fans continue to uncover layers of meaning in Red Dead Redemption 2, speculation about the franchise's future is growing. News of a potential Red Dead Redemption 3 remains a distant dream, with Rockstar currently focusing on the highly anticipated Grand Theft Auto 6. For now, fans can only theorize about what might come next. Until Rockstar is ready to share more, players will continue to explore the rich, immersive world of Red Dead Redemption 2, uncovering its secrets piece by piece.